1887 N172 Old Judge Joe Crotty (102-5) PSA 2 - Baseball Catcher
Price: USD 525.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 063**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
N172 Old Judge 1887 Tim Keefe Pitch R/Hand Forward PSA 4 12374
Price: USD 4851.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 074**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 25.25
Read More
Rare! 1887 Old Judge N172 OLD HOSS RADBOURN /BILLY NASH TAGGING PLAYER -PSA AUTH
Price: USD 5999.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 060**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 50.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Billy Sunday (446-1) PSA 2 - Baseball Evangelist
Price: USD 2475.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 063**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 9.45
Read More
JOHN CLARKSON 1887 N172 Old Judge PSA 1 Throwing Right Hand Hip High CHICAGO HOF
Price: USD 1299.95
Condition: Graded
Location: 170**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 9.95
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Charles Bastian PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 455.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Tim Keefe Bat At Ready 30• PSA 1.5
Price: USD 2800.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 074**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 23.25
Read More
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE BASEBALL CARD CAPT JOHN WARD NEW YORK GIANTS HOF GOODWIN PSA
Price: USD 2900.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE SAMUEL BARKLEY KANSAS CITY PSA 1 POP 1 ULTRA RARE
Price: USD 475.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 300**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 10.00
Read More
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE SILVER FLINT BAT AT READYY PSA PR 1 BB
Price: USD 600.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 8.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge John Ward PSA 5 Hands On Hips
Price: USD 5500.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 074**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 25.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Yank Robinson PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 455.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Dave Orr PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 630.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Con Daley Throw, Right Hand Head High PSA 2
Price: USD 400.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 524**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 4.75
Read More
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Dan Casey Philadelphia Phillies PSA pose 72-3 RARE
Price: USD 459.99
Condition: Graded
Location: 282**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge 490-2 pose Buck West PSA 1.5 Minneapolis
Price: USD 485.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 063**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Ned Williamson PSA 1 - POOR
Price: USD 410.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge John Clarkson Throwing Right Arm Extended PSA 3 VG
Price: USD 3500.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 152**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 40.00
Read More
1887 Buck Ewing N172 Old Judge HOF Bat Hand PSA 3.5 RC Rookie New York
Price: USD 3570.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 17.95
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Mike Dorgan PSA 2 (MC) - GOOD
Price: USD 400.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes Mike Dorgan PSA 6 New York Giants
Price: USD 3250.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Charles Hoover - PSA Authentic Chicago HIGH END
Price: USD 359.95
Condition: Graded
Location: 980**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 4.95
Read More
1989 Old Judge N172 Thomas Flanigan (Sioux City) #162-1 SGC Authentic
Price: USD 300.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 551**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 10.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Fred Pfeffer PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 410.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N174 Old Judge Prizefighter series Jack McAuliffe PSA 1.5 SUPER RARE
Price: USD 300.20
Condition: Graded
Location: T6W***
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 17.66
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Clark Griffith HOF PSA 1 (MK) - POOR
Price: USD 910.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Gil Hatfield New York PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 630.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Gil Hatfield Catch Hands Cupped Ball Above Head 1.5 POP 1
Price: USD 1999.99
Condition: Graded
Location: 531**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes Shorty Radford PSA 4 Cleveland Spiders
Price: USD 1750.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarette Card WILLIAM SCHENKEL Milwaukee P. PSA A Pop 4
Price: USD 594.95
Condition: Graded
Location: 178**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge #225-4b Ed Herr PSA 3 Bat in R/Hand at side Milwaukees
Price: USD 800.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 524**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 4.75
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Silent Mike Tiernan PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 840.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Nick Nicholl PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 455.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Jack Clements PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 510.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge #50-1 Charles Buffington Buffinton PSA 4 - Philadelphia
Price: USD 1625.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 063**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Bill Farmer PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 810.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge William Pop Schriver PSA 7 - POP 1, none higher - Phila
Price: USD 1500.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 19.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BOB CARUTHERS Brooklyns PSA 1.5 CAREER 218-99
Price: USD 1395.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Frank Wells Milwaukee GRADED PSA Authentic Altered RARE
Price: USD 449.98
Condition: Graded
Location: 891**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Farmer # PSA 2
Price: USD 545.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 197**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge, Dan Brouthers, Detroit Bat/Ready Over Shoulder, PSA Auth.
Price: USD 2095.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Jeremiah Denny PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 520.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill George PSA 3
Price: USD 699.00
Condition: Used
Location: 801**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Silver Flint PSA 5 - EX
Price: USD 940.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge FRANK DWYER Chicago Cubs PSA 1.5 Fair Condition
Price: USD 499.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 077**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 4.50
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Billy O'Brien PSA 1.5 - FAIR
Price: USD 365.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Ed Morris PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 455.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Henry Gruber PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 455.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BILL BISHOP Pittsburgh PSA 2
Price: USD 995.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Sidney Farrar Phillies PSA 3.5 - VG+
Price: USD 630.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
Hugh Duffy 1887 N172 Old Judge Braves HOF Rookie SGC 1.5
Price: USD 1500.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 023**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Thomas Nagle PSA 2.5 - GD+
Price: USD 630.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Cy Sutcliffe Looking At Ball By Bat PSA 3 P1315
Price: USD 550.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 600**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N174 Mike Clearly Prizefighter boxing PSA 1 (MK) Beauty card
Price: USD 282.55
Condition: Graded
Location: T6W***
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 17.66
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Julie Freeman PSA 5 - EX
Price: USD 950.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Dad Clarke PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 770.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Stephen Toole PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 900.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DICK BUCKLEY BASEBALL CARD CATCH HANDS INDIANAPOLIS PSA 3
Price: USD 995.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Edward Herr PSA 2.5 - GD+
Price: USD 500.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge, Ned Hanlon, Bat in R/Hand at side, PSA Poor-1, marks, HOF
Price: USD 2395.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge PARK SWARTZEL (Pitch, hands by L/shoulder) - PSA 5 EX
Price: USD 535.50
Condition: Graded
Location: 801**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 12.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Lev Shreve PSA 5 - EX
Price: USD 990.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card John SOWDERS Kansas City Cowboy PSA 5 Centered
Price: USD 1900.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes Jack Clements Bat at Ready Nearly Vertical PSA 5
Price: USD 1500.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 928**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Mike Mattimore PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 950.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge #86-2 CHARLES COMISKEY HOF! PSA 2 GOOD MK [Sliding]
Price: USD 2299.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 334**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 12.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Jay Faatz PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 770.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Tom Daly CHICAGO (Hands on Knees) PSA 3
Price: USD 1195.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Sid Farrar Right Hand At Belt PSA 4 (MC) P1332
Price: USD 700.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 600**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Gus Albert Cleveland Throwing PSA 2
Price: USD 1195.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge SCRAPPY Carroll ST. PAUL Baseball Card PSA 4 vg/ex
Price: USD 1395.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1889 Old Judge N172 Ed Silch Denversne SGC 1.5 Strong Image
Price: USD 399.95
Condition: Graded
Location: 980**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
1887-89 Old Judge George Pinkney PSA Authentic Altered Brooklyn N172 Goodwin
Price: USD 705.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 913**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 10.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Albert Mays PSA 2.5 - GD+
Price: USD 620.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Black Jack Burdock PSA 2(MK) Boston Beaneaters
Price: USD 1350.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 331**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 19.99
Read More
1886-87 old Judge N172 #84-5 Bill Collins psa graded AUTHENTIC Baseball Card
Price: USD 500.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 660**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 William Holbert PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 760.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Bill Krieg PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 860.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Ned Bligh PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 520.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Danny Richardson PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 850.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge William Klusman Catch Hands High Denver PSA 4 P1311
Price: USD 935.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 600**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Peter Wood PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 760.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Curtis Welch PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 1000.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Samuel Wise PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 770.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Robert Gilks PSA 4.5 - VG/EX+
Price: USD 820.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Michael Goodfellow PSA 4 - VG/EX
Price: USD 850.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Albert Maul PSA 2 - GOOD
Price: USD 640.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Con Daley PSA 2.5 - GD+
Price: USD 640.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
Wallace Ross 1887 N174 Old Judge Prizefighter PSA 5-Rare!
Price: USD 1850.25
Condition: Graded
Location: 982**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 20.00
Read More
Jack Dempsey 1887 N174 Old Judge Prizefighter Rookie PSA 3
Price: USD 1530.50
Condition: Graded
Location: 982**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 20.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 Honest John Boyle PSA 2.5 - GD+
Price: USD 860.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 George Dandy Wood PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 680.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card DAD CLARKE Chicago SGC 4 VG/EX
Price: USD 1295.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 864**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1889 N173 Old Judge Cabinet Bill Hallman SGC 3.5 - Philadelphia - POP 1 highest!
Price: USD 1750.00
Condition: Graded
Location:
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 22.00
Read More
1887 Old Judge N172 George Doggie Miller Pirates PSA 3 - VG
Price: USD 790.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 452**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.99
Read More
N172 Old Judge Cabinet Card George Sleepy Townsend With Ball 1888 1/1 G&B Studio
Price: USD 1299.00
Condition: Ungraded
Location: 088**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
Mike Cleary 1888 N174 Goodwin Old Judge Prizefighter PSA 3 (MK) 1887-1980
Price: USD 850.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 653**
Shipping Type: CALCULATED
Shipping Cost: USD
Read More
1887 N172 "Old Judge" Pat Dealy (Catcher - Washington) SGC 8 Extremely sharp!
Price: USD 4250.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 537**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 OLD JUDGE N174 BOXING JP CLOW PSA 6 POP 1 NONE HIGHER RARE 3638
Price: USD 3000.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 662**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 0.00
Read More
1887 OLD JUDGE RIP VAN HALTREN VG BAT AT READY WHITE STOCKINGS PSA 3
Price: USD 960.00
Condition: Graded
Location: 805**
Shipping Type: FIXED
Shipping Cost: USD 5.00
Read More- 1